Question:
I am the managing partner in a twelve-lawyer estate litigation law firm in Chicago. I believe that our firm needs to be doing much more with AI implementation in our firm. We are using AI for legal research, litigation support, and general case related support activities. However, we have not implemented AI at all in general administrative and accounting operations which are areas where we have five staff employees handling a variety of tasks. I believe that we are inefficient and over staffed. I am having a tough time finding where to start so we can get a handle on this issue. Please provide any information that you are willing to share.
Response:
Before you can successfully implement AI and related tools to improve administrative and accounting operations and related processes you need to review and understand existing work distribution and workflow and identify and fix any work distribution and workflow issues. I would start with a work distribution analysis and workflow study.
There are questions that you must ask yourself in order to analyze the work distribution of your intake and accounting operations. Such questions as the following will help you in knowing what to look for:
Before you can analyze your client intake and accounting operations you must be able to see clearly, in one place, all the activities of your client intake and accounting operations and the contribution of each employee on each activity. A work distribution chart is the easiest and best way to arrange these facts in simple form. A properly made work distribution chart will help you determine if the largest time of your staff is devoted to the major function of each operation. Setup a work distribution chart (spreadsheet) with operations and tasks listed down the left rows and staff names listed across the columns with time listed for each operation and task. It may indicate that more time is being devoted to other functions than is necessary. An operation or task may require a more detailed study, as might be indicated where total hours seem unreasonable. You may discover that your client intake and accounting operations staff are spending too much time on relatively unimportant or unnecessary work. Misdirected effort appears on the work distribution chart when staff are involved in tasks not contribution directly to the mission of the client intake or accounting operations.
Here is an overview of the work distribution analysis process:
One you have completed the work distribution analysis, prepare a work flow analysis using a drawing tool such as Microsoft Visio or other suitable drawing tool.
Once you have fixed any issues that become evident from your study they you can identify candidate areas for workflow automation and possible AI adoption. Start with reviewing work flow capabilities in your existing practice management software and any recent AI capabilities that have been implemented in your software or are planned for the future.
Click here for our blog on human resources
Click here for our blog on profit improvement
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D., CMC
Question:
I am the founding partner and sole owner in our firm located in Miami, Florida. We have a total of four lawyers, four paralegals, and four support staff in our firm. We are an estate planning firm that handles estate planning, estate administration, and elder law matters for our clients. Estate planning matters are charged a flat fee and estate administration are billed based on time spent on the matter. At a recent attorney meeting the subject of AI and the impact upon estate planning came up and our discussion led us to the question as to the impact that AI will have upon future estate planning work for our practice. Will estate planning dry up with clients using AI tools and doing their own estate planning documents? Your comments and thoughts are most welcomed.
Response:
I believe that AI will have an impact upon estate planning, especially for wills and trusts in that it will change how wills and trusts are drafted. You will be forced to use AI assisted drafting tools if you are not using them already and the use of these tools will substantially reduce drafting time. More firms will be forced to move from hourly billing to flat fee billing for estate planning work. As efficiency improves and firms that are presently charging flat fees will see competitors charging less, reducing average revenue per matter and required a larger volume of client business to remain competitive. AI will impact how:
In order to remain competitive and profitable in the next three to five years estate planning law firms are going to have to:
Your goal should be to graduate from lawyer technician to a trusted advisor to your clients. A trusted advisor is a lawyer or other professional service provider whom a client relies on not merely for knowledge or technical expertise, but for sound judgment, honest counsel, and guidance in making important decisions. Trust is earned over time through competence, integrity, discretion, consistency, and a genuine commitment to the client’s interests.
As a trusted advisor estate planning attorney your primary role should be to understand the family’s complete circumstances, identify the questions the client has not considered, and develop a coordinated plan that reflects the client’s wishes. Your role should not be to primarily prepare estate planning documents. Your role should be to help clients make decisions about family, responsibility, control, and legacy. This is the difference between a technician whose work will be replaced by AI and a trusted advisor whose work will be focused on client relationships.
Click here for our blog on strategy.
Click here for our blog on management
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D., CMC
Question:
Our firm is a small general practice firm with three partners and two associates in Southern Illinois. We have been deploying AI for the past year primarily in our litigation cases and have experienced time savings and efficiencies from using AI tools. Since our litigation cases were all contingency fee cases AI did increase our profitability on these cases – we are not sure about our time bill matters. As managing partner in the firm, I am wondering what the impact of AI is going to have on our business and management strategy going forward. What are your thoughts?
Response:
Artificial intelligence is changing the way legal services are delivered. From legal research and document review to drafting, client communication, and administrative support, AI tools are creating opportunities for law firms to improve efficiency and rethink how work gets done.
Adopting AI is only part of the equation. The more important question is whether law firm management is keeping pace with these changes. Technology alone will not fix inefficient processes, unclear responsibilities, weak financial controls, or a lack of strategic direction. Implementing AI into a poorly managed firm can amplify existing problems.
AI Implementation as a Management Issue
You should approach AI implementation primarily as a management issue and you should identify and determine management issues that need to be resolved. For example:
After you have identified these issues, you can determine whether AI is an appropriate solution and where to prioritize implementation.
AI should be implemented to improve the way the firm operates, serves clients, and improves profitability by by reducing time spent on certain routine tasks, helping staff work more efficiently, and allowing attorneys to devote more attention to higher-value legal work and client relationships.
Impact Upon Profitability
You need to realize that increased efficiency does not automatically translate into increased profit if you do not consider client billing methods used in your firm. If AI reduces the time required to complete tasks performed for clients and the firm continues to bill based on time spent and the billable hour, the result may be reduced revenues and reduced profitability. You may need to consider a different approach to client billing.
You must examine how the firm charges for its services, prices matters, allocates work, and measures attorney productivity. Under alternative fee arrangements, efficiency gains may improve margins directly. In hourly billing practices, firms may need to reconsider staffing, pricing, and how released capacity is used to serve clients and develop new business.
AI Policy
Uncoordinated adoption can lead to inconsistent practices, duplicated spending, security concerns, and uncertainty about which tools are approved for client work. You should establish AI policies in writing addressing:
Training
Attorneys and staff need to understand both the capabilities and limitations of the tools they use. AI-generated content can contain errors, unsupported statements, or fabricated legal authorities. Professional judgment and independent verification remain essential. Your goal should encourage responsible experimentation within a framework that protects clients and the firm.
Next Steps
I suggest that you begin with a focus on your firm’s management strategy rather than AI technology and what others are doing. Start with the following steps:
These steps should be part of a broader management plan that includes budgeting, staffing, pricing, business development, and strategic planning. AI should support the firm’s business objectives rather than become a separate initiative disconnected from them.
Your objective should not be to make a law firm more technologically sophisticated simply for the sake of innovation. The objective is to build a better-managed firm—one that delivers quality legal services, serves clients effectively, develops its people, and achieves sustainable financial performance.
Click here for our blog on strategy.
Click here for our blog on management
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D., CMC
Question:
I am the managing partner of a sixteen-lawyer insurance-defense firm in Orlando, Florida. There are four equity partners in the firm, twelve associates, and eight paralegals plus administrative personnel. We manage the defense for various insurance company’s insured primary in auto accidents, premises liability, and slip and falls cases. Our work comes primarily from four insurance companies. All of our clients are billed by the hour at low hourly rates with restrictions on the amount of time that we can spend on certain matters. We have resisted using any form of AI and we are continuing to staff our client cases as we have always done. Our clients are asking us what and how we are implementing AI and to reduce associate and paralegal time spend on their cases. I realize that we must change our ways and begin to implement some level of AI in our practice. However, I have concerns as to how we survive in a practice where partner livelihood in a low bill rate practice has been based on high billable hours and the profit margin off of associates and paralegals. What do you see as the impact that AI is having or going to have on insurance-defense law firms?
Response:
AI is likely to have a major impact on insurance-defense law firms. Associates may not be totally replaced as firms will be able to handle more cases with fewer billable hours. Insurance companies will expect faster turnaround of their cases at lower costs. Implementation of AI by insurance company outside law firms will be a requirement.
Insurance-defense law firms will see the following changes:
When it is all said and done a major question will be:
With reduced billable hours insurance-defense firms will have to either reduce associate/paralegal headcount or increase their case volumes. Business development will become more critical as opposed to simply relying on a handful of insurance company clients.
While AI is having and will continue to have a transformational impact upon society as well as law firms, we have seen this before with other forms of technology and law firms have successfully adapted and I believe that we will once again.
Click here for our blog on strategy.
Click here for our blog on management
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D., CMC