Question:
I am the managing partner of a small boutique litigation firm in Southern, California. There are two equity partners in the firm and five associates. Two of our associates have been with us for 8 and 15 years respectively and are critical to the success of our practice. We do not want to lose them, so we are considering making them non-equity partners and giving them the title of partner. We are not ready for equity partners at this time. All associates in the firm are paid a salary and a discretionary bonus. How can we make their promotion to partner meaningful and successful?
Response:
Promoting your first associate to a non-equity partner is a significant step and should not be taken without giving it serious thought and it’s long term implications for the firm in terms of overall career advancement for not just your present two associates but also other associates in the firm as well as others that may join the firm in the future.
Non-equity-partnership should be one step in an overall attorney career advancement program (partner track) that recognizes leadership and professional accomplishment while creating expectations for increased responsibility, client development, and firm management. Your attorney career advancement program should be consistent and fair.
Several of my clients are developing career advancement programs that incorporate a competency-based approach that outlines specifically what is takes to be successful and advance from associate to non-equity partner and from non-equity partner to equity partner. Rather than leaving the formula for success in the minds of the equity partners, a competency model gives each attorney in the firm an understanding of how he or she will need to perform in order to be perceived as progressing, and ultimately, as successful. Competency models offer transparency and clarity. The model outlines specific behavioral observations as the primary source of performance information. Benefits are as follows:
Associates are presented with clear information on expectations for their level of experience and a road map of what is expected as they progress. Specific expectations are laid out for progression to non-equity partner as opposed to a specific timeline.
Non-equity partners are presented with clear information on expectations for their level of experience and a road map of what is expected as they progress. Specific expectations are laid out for progression to equity-partner as opposed to a specific timeline.
Equity partners and senior lawyers benefit from a consistent description of performance standards that allow them to access performance, assign work effectively, and offer more meaningful career guidance.
The firm has a consistent methodology for making compensation decisions.
Concerning Non-Equity Partnership, the Firm Should Consider the Following:
Give Some Thought and Define Why the Firm Will Have Non-Equity Partners
The firm should clearly define the purpose of the non-equity partner role. Consider questions such as:
Develop Performance Criteria and Incorporate in Your Attorney Career Advancement Program (Partner Track)
Associates should understand the firm’s expectations before they are eligible for consideration.
Typical criteria might include:
Evaluate Associate Performance
Promotion should reflect more time worked at the firm.
You should consider whether the associate:
Consider Whether the Associate Develops or Has the Ability to Develop and Bring in Business.
Consider Leadership Contributions
Partnership involves leadership beyond practicing law.
Are associates involved in:
Review Financial Performance
Relevant performance criteria:
Client Satisfaction
Determine Role in Firm Management
Consider Developing Non-Equity Partner Compensation System
The firm should consider a different compensation system for non-equity partners. Approaches might consider the following:
Consider Additional Perks
Conduct a Comprehensive Performance Review
An effective evaluation typically includes:
A structured process promotes fairness and consistency.
Announce Non-Equity Partner Promotions Internally and Externally
Common Pitfalls with Non-Equity Partnership Programs
A thoughtful attorney career advancement program (partner track) improves the odds of success for both the attorney and the law firm. It recognizes professional achievement while ensuring that new non-equity partners support the firm’s long-term success.
Click here for our blog on partnership
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am a partner in a fourteen lawyer firm in Des Moines, Iowa with seven equity partners (shareholders) and seven associates. We are a business litigation firm exclusively. The seven equity partners (shareholders) have all been practicing law for fifteen years. We formed the firm five years ago when we all left a large law firm in area. The firm is structured as a professional corporation (PC). For the past five years we have managed the firm as a group with the seven of us making all of the management decisions. This requires us coming together at least once a week and often even more frequently. While this worked for us when we were smaller the amount of non-billable time it taking a toll on all of us. We have come to the realization that we have outgrown our management structure and are looking for a better approach to managing our firm. We are looking for ideas and would appreciate any ideas that you may have.
Response:
I understand your frustration and your experience is typical what I see in newly started law firms. While the approach you have taken to managing the firm made sense and worked when you started the firm five years ago, you have simply outgrown this approach and need to move to a governance/management structure more appropriate for a fourteen lawyer law firm. For a fourteen lawyer firm with seven equity partners, you have enough partners to benefit from more formal governance, but you don’t need the bureaucracy of a large-firm model. The key is separating day-to-day management from major ownership decisions.
Most smaller to medium sized law firms choose one of three fundamental varieties of management structure. These systems may be characterized as management by:
Democratic
This is the method that you have been operating under. Under a democracy each member of the firm has an equal voice in management. Any decision must be agreed to by all partners. Administrative tasks may be assigned or rotated among partners. Democratic firms traditionally progress more slowly and are less profitable than firms governed under one of the other structural models.
Managing Partner
This approach with a strong managing partner is probably the most efficient form of managing a law firm. Under this approach the administrative responsibilities for other partners in the firm may simplified as the result of the managing partner’s role, however this type of structure has many shortcomings and issues. Egos of the partners is a major issue is many firms. Also the managing partner came become overloaded with firm decisions and his or her law practice, as well as the firm, may suffer financially. The managing partner may not be able to devote the time or follow-through required to handle organizational and financial matters. Since no other partner may be trained in managing the firm, this partner may not feel comfortable in relinquishing power to anyone else. This is a problem which may be especially troublesome if the managing partner dies, becomes ill or disabled.
Some attorneys may be dismayed at the prospect of having their firm dominated by an individual or group of partners. However, if properly handled, this form of structure can be productive, and economically and professionally rewarding. To be effective, the managing partner should maintain communication with other partners. The managing partner should seek advice from other partners (and associates) on matters that will affect them. The managing partner should obtain other partners’ input on decisions, appoint individuals or committees of partners to perform particular functions and require a report of their achievements.
Executive or Management Committee
The executive or management committee structural concept is a representative form of governance typified by a committee of partners having defined authority, accountability and responsibility. In most smaller firms this committee, frequently consisting of three partners, may be responsible for recommending and implementing policy for the firm, planning for the future, appraising results and recommending corrective action, as required.
I believe that a three partner executive or management committee might be the best approach for your firm and would be the best way to avoid deadlocks or inaction and to spread the burden of firm management among appropriate partners. One of the partners should be designated to chair the committee. Each of the other members may be assigned authority, responsibility and accountability for coordinating and/or performing specific functions. For example, one partner may serve as the financial partner. This would involve responsibility for insuring the preparation and analysis of income and expense budgets and financial reporting. This partner would oversee attorney production, fees, collections, etc. A second partner may be responsible for the personnel functions including associate career development, i.e., employment, training, evaluation, etc., and implementation of policy for the administrative staff. A third partner may serve as the general administrative partner, and oversee the implementation of administrative policy, systems, automation, etc. These partners may be assisted by an office manager, bookkeeper, etc.
To preserve continuity in the management function, it is recommended that tenure of partners on the executive or management committee be staggered over a two or three year period. The executive committee should communicate with the partners regularly or as issues arise. The executive committee should meet weekly, or if that isn’t convenient, as frequently as required. To keep all of the partners apprised of issues before the executive committee meeting is held, it is recommended that the meeting agenda be distributed to all partners within 48 hours prior to the scheduled meeting. Partners should be encouraged to discuss, with members of the executive committee, any items listed on the agenda or recommend subjects for discussion. Following this meeting, minutes should be prepared and distributed to all of the partners for information purposes.
Meetings with all of the partners (shareholders) should be scheduled at least quarterly and possibly even monthly.
You did not indicate whether your firm has a firm administrator on your staff. I believe that this may be a good time to consider hiring a firm administrator and that role should be incorporated into the firm’s management/governance plan. The firm administrator should handle all administrative matters and the the management committee should focus on higher level management matters. The full equity shareholder membership should weight in only on matters reserved for their vote and approval.
You should document your governance/management structure in your shareholder agreement. For example:
Specific policy matters that might be reserved for full equity shareholder vote might include:
Specific policy matters that might be the domain of the management/executive committee might include:
Your shareholder agreement should clarify who decides what, by what vote, and within what financial/authority limits. It should address management, voting thresholds, partner rights/duties, compensation, and partner withdrawals.
Click here for our blog on management
Click here for our blog on governance
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am the sole owner of a 20 lawyer litigation firm in Chicago. There are five seasoned non-equity partners and fourteen associates in the firm. I am 63 and trying to figure out what to do with the practice. While I am not ready to retire in the next several years I do want to slow down and be retired in five to seven years. How should I approach my transition and exit from the firm? You feedback would be appreciated.
Response:
You have a valid concern that is shared by many.
The pending retirement of the baby boomer generation and the unrelenting challenge of finding and keeping talented staff can have grave consequences for law firms that fail to develop a succession strategy. Steps that you take or do not take five years or earlier prior to your actual retirement will determine whether your practice, clients, employees, and your legacy transitions to another generation. For a small or solo practice, these steps may determine whether your practice has any terminal value at all.
Many are asking, “What do I do with this Practice?” “Is there value or goodwill? “Where and how should I start?
Early planning will pay dividends. Many firms are in “reactionary mode” and are not adequately prepared to transition firm leadership and client relationships. A firm’s very survival may very well depend upon the steps you begin taking in the next few years.
How well you transition clients and managerial roles will determine the ultimate success of any succession/exit plan. Transition of clients and managerial roles are the two critical components of any succession/exit plan.
Bring Deserving and Qualified Non-Equity Partners into Equity
Personally, I believe your best strategy will be to bring some of your non-equity partners into equity sooner than later – either with initial buy-ins or no buy-ins for initial ownership minority shares but agreed to buyouts for your remaining equity upon your requirement. We are finding a lot of non-takers today when it comes to equity and you need to find out sooner than later if you have anyone interested in equity. This will determine whether your strategy will be an internal exit strategy or external strategy.
Client Transition
Transitioning client relationships is difficult, it takes time, and it takes more than one simple introduction. It is a lot like cross selling that attorneys talk about but often fail to put into practice.
In a recent BTI Consulting Group report on Benchmarking Law Firm Marketing and Business Development Strategies, the section on cross-selling was titled, “Achilles Heel for Law Firms.” When BTI interviewed 120 Chief Marketing Officers and Directors of Business Development at leading law firms, they found that only 4 percent of law firms rated themselves as highly effective in cross-selling, and 77 percent thought they were ineffective.
My experience and our surveys of our clients and their clients have shown similar results. Cross-selling is talked about a lot and seldom implemented.
Cross-selling can be an effective strategy – but it is not easy and it requires trust, commitment, communication, hard work, dedication, and organizational alignment.
Challenges and Hurdles
Transitioning clients to another responsible attorney(s) within your law firm or to another attorney in another law firm involves numerous challenges that have to be overcome. Consider the following challenges and hurdles:
Client Transition
Successful client transition – moving clients from one generation to the next – is a major challenge for all law firms. Shifting clients is not an individual responsibility but a firm responsibility. To effectively transition clients the individual lawyer, with clients, must work together with the firm to insure the clients receive quality legal services throughout the transition process. Both the individual lawyer and the firm must be committed to keeping clients in the firm when the senior attorneys retire. Potential obstacles include:
Transitioning institutional client relationships effectively can and where possible should take a number of years – preferably five years – typically not less than three years.
The following client transition plan might be an approach you could take to transition clients over a three to five year period:
Effective client transition takes time so start early. Clients hire lawyers not law firms.
Management Transition
Successful management transition – moving management and leadership from one generation to the next – can also be a major challenge.
Consider undertaking the following, as well as other, management and leadership activities, which may assist you and the firm transition management and leadership roles over the next three to five years.
An effective succession and transition strategy involves coming to terms with aging and retirement, developing a timeline, and identifying transition candidates either internally or externally. An old saying at IBM when I was a business partner with IBM – what gets planned and what get measured is what gets done. You have worked hard to build your practice. Your practice may or may not have value depending upon the steps you take and when you take them. Start early.
Click here for our blog on succession strategies
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am the founder and owner of a business law firm in San Diego, California. There are 9 associates, four paralegals, and three administrative staff members working in the firm. I founded the practice 20 years ago and I have never had a partner in this firm. I was involved in a partnership in another firm prior to forming this firm. There were partnership issues which is the reason why I left and started my own firm. I have enjoyed the freedom of sole ownership but I now believe that in order to get to the next level, retain quality attorneys, and have a succession plan for myself when I get closer to retirement I need to consider bringing in partners. However, based on my prior firm experience I am fearful. I would appreciate your thoughts and advice.
Response:
Do You Really Want Partners
You may want to ask yourself whether you want employees or partners. What is the criteria for becoming an equity partner? Is client development part of that criteria? Should they contribute capital? If they are not adding value to the firm – growth – you may be diluting the earnings pool and reducing the size of the pie for yourself. Personally, I think in small firms criteria for becoming an equity partner should, among other things, include client development and a capital contribution. They should have some skin in the game, contribute capital, and signup for their share of the liabilities. I also believe they should then be included in the inner circle.
Then, depending upon whether you are considering equity and non-equity partner tiers, you should develop non-equity and associate career progression plans – associate to non-equity partner and non-equity partner to equity partner – outlining timeline for consideration, the consideration process, the criteria, and the responsibilities and expectations for each. (What partnership means)
You may believe that you have identified the right person or persons whom you believe is the right person or persons for partnership. However, just because the associate has been a good associate does not mean that the associate will be a good partner – the relationship will be different. But at least the associate is somewhat of a known quantity since you know the associate and have worked with the associate for several years.
Here are a few ideas you might consider:
Hiring Associates That Can Be Effectively Groomed for Partnership
Years ago it seemed that all the associates working in law firms wanted to eventually become a partner in the law firm. This has changed as a result of the new mix of women and men graduating from law schools and entering the legal profession, changing attitudes toward work life balance, other opportunities outside law firms, and other variables. While partnership/ownership is still important to many – don’t assume that all the associates that you hire will even want to be equity partners – especially if it means a hefty capital contribution and signing personal guarantees for a large amount of firm debt.
A question that I would ask – have you really discussed with your associates their interests in equity ownership? As a group? Recently an associate, whom the firm had written off, advised me that while he was not interested now due to his present situation in life, he would be in maybe five years – especially if others also were brought in as well – in other words he did not want to have the responsibility alone and be an equity owner by himself.
I suggest that you talk with your people and see where they really stand. Help them to begin developing client development skills. Depending on your retirement timeline – and if you have “no takers” you may have to consider other options such as laterals or merging with another firm.
A key suggestion is to look for entrepreneurial associates when you hire. The desire for ownership of a business if often in a person’s blood. Don’t start the interview with a discussion from law school until the present. Dig deeper into hobbies, general interests, etc. that will provide clues as to whether you may be hiring someone that just wants a law job or someone that eventually wants to own or be a partner in a law firm.
Typically a buy-in or capital contribution is not required for non-equity partners nor do I recommend such. Typically non-equity partners are salaried and may participate in some form of an incentive bonus system tied to individual, team, or firm financial performance. They are also not required to assume any responsibility for any of the firm’s financial liabilities or debts.
If you intend on bringing in the associates as equity partners that is another matter. I believe that all new partners should be expected to contribute capital and have some “skin in the game.” Whenever a firm admits a new partner, the firm should require the new partner to contribute capital. Increasingly, a partner’s capital requirement should bear a relationship to the partner’s share of profits. You may want to allow new partners a reasonable period of time to fund their capital accounts – say five years or help them arrange favorable terms at your bank to finance their capital accounts.
Some firms have a buy-in tied to either the cash-based book value of the firm or the accrual-based book value (includes accounts receivable and work in process). This is not the typical practice although I do run into it. Usually capital accounts are tied to working capital needed to operate the firm and the percentage of ownership/income that each partner will have.
There are only three ways to increase a firm’s working capital to cover cash flow requirements and fund growth:
1. Have partners put more money in
2. Have partners take less money out
3. Borrow
Many firms use bank credit lines instead of capital contributions to pay routine firm expenses and partner draws during periods when cash flow is tight. It has been my experience that firms that follow this practice have ongoing financial challenges and problems.
The reality is that many firms are under-capitalized – don’t become one of them!
Make the criteria tough and resist the temptation to make everyone a partner.
Click here for our blog on partnership
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am the sole owner of a personal injury practice in Orlando, Florida. I am in my mid-sixties and am looking to transition out of the firm and retire in the next five to seven years. I have three associates in the firm. I would like to sell my equity to one of the associates that has expressed an interest and has been with me for many years. I would like to receive some value for founding the firm and my contributions over the past thirty years. I would like to see him a twenty percent interest initially and more over the next few years. I am trying to determine a firm value for calculating his buy-in. I would appreciate any thoughts that you may have regarding how buy-ins for partners are determined.
Response:
Approaches to buy-ins and buyouts are all over the place in law firms. Here are a few of the common approaches:
In the final analysis the value of the practice is what an outside buyer or an attorney working for the firm will pay for (or invest) the practice. A balance often has to be struck between valuation, affordability, and willingness to pay. The valuation process is simply a tool to use to help you begin discussions and get to this point.
Click here for our blog on succession
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am one of three founding partners in a 12 lawyer general litigation firm in San Francisco. All three of us are in are sixties and are looking to begin admitting others as equity partners. We have three non-equity partners and five associates in the firm. The three of believe that we should receive some value for founding the firm and our contributions over the past twenty years. We would like to sell each of them a ten percent interest and we are trying to determine a firm value for calculating their buy-ins.
Response:
In the final analysis the value of the practice is what an outside buyer or an attorney working for the firm will pay for (or invest) the practice. A balance often has to be struck between valuation, affordability, and willingness to pay. The valuation process is simply a tool to use to help you begin discussions and get to this point.
I believe that firm value has to be balanced with affordability and a prospective equity member’s willingness and ability to pay for the shares. It all comes down to compensation. Generally, I find that a prospective equity member or partner must be able to see a significant compensation increase with a breakeven/payback period of around three years – no more than five. I also believe that when shares are seller financed the period should be no longer than five years. Many firms do not sell shares based on formal valuation – other methods are used.
Questions that equity member candidates usually raise:
In many law firms’ compensation is based upon performance and contribution and ownership shares have little or no bearing on member or partner compensation. Their primary goal is to acquire and retain talent.
Use a valuation methodology as a starting point – such as a multiple of firm past five year’s average revenue and adjust for the affordability factor. Keep in mind that many of your competitors are offering equity partnership with no buy-ins at all.
Click here for our blog on succession
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
Our firm is a seventeen lawyer insurance defense firm in Austin, Texas. The firm was founded by the two existing partners twenty-five years ago. In addition to the three founding equity partners we have five non-equity partners and ten associates. Non-equity partners and associates are paid a salary and a discretionary bonus. The two equity partners are paid their profit share based upon their partnership percentage which is fifty percent each in the form of distributions dependent upon cash flow. The two of us are considering offering partnership to two non-equity partners with a buy-in based on selling both a five percent interest based on a designed price per share. We would to maintain our same method of equity partner compensation based on percentage interest. We would appreciate any ideas that you have.
Response:
This approach would be fine if the compensation numbers work. I often find that at the lower end of partnership equity shares the compensation model that you have been using no longer works. The new partner simply does not have enough of an equity share interest to compensate him or her fairly and or be competitive with other law firms. He or she may ending up making less than they were making as non-equity partners. It may be time to at least shift to a compensation model for all of you where each of you are paid a base salary based upon your years of experience, billings, and overall performance and contribution to the firm, a bonus pool for exceptional performance or contribution to the firm, and the remainder distributed based on partnership ownership shares. Take a look at the non-equity partner candidates, their present compensation, what other law firms are paying that you are competing with for talent, and go from there. Also consider the buy-in that you are asking for and whether it is affordable and reasonable and how many years it will take your candidates to breakeven on the investment. Today we are finding that more and more non-equity partners and associates are saying “no thanks” to equity offers.
Of course there are many other approaches that you could take concerning compensation but this recommendation seems the easiest and closest to your present approach.
Click here for our blog on compensation
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I and another partner are the owners of a seven lawyer family law practice in Chicago suburbs. We started the firm twenty years ago after leaving behind a partnership in another firm. Of the other five attorneys there are three non-equity partners and the rest are associates. I am sixty three years old and my other partner is sixty. Both of us are beginning to think about retirement and how we are going to transition out of the practice. Two of the non-equity partners are well seasoned attorneys, have major case responsibility, and bring in client business. We have discussed equity partnership vaguely with two non-equity partners but they have been non-committal. I would appreciate your thoughts and advice on what our next steps should be.
Response:
I believe that you have been two vague in your discussions. Your non-equity partners need to know what the deal is, what financial investment will be required, and what their expected return will be based upon the historical financial performance of the firm. It is hard for non-equity partners or associates to commit to equity and taking on the risk of ownership when they don’t know what the deal is. This is a scary proposition for them and they need detailed information so they can evaluate and make an informed decision. A vague discussion doesn’t cut it. I suggest that you put together an equity partnership proposal that includes:
Click here for our blog on succession
Click here for out articles on various management topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am one of three founding partners in a fourteen lawyer firm in Cleveland, Ohio. We are an insurance defense firm with three founding partners, five non-equity partners, and six associates. We have three primary insurance companies that refer a majority of cases to the firm. All three of us founding partners are in our early to mid sixties and contemplating our retirement and departure from the firm in the next five to eight years. Our lease runs out in eight years and none of us want to sign another lease. Three of our non-equity partners are in their mid to late fifties and two are in their forties. All of our associates have less than five years experience. When and how should we begin planning for our retirements and exits from the firm?
Response:
I suggest that you start now, especially if you are planning on an internal succession strategy. I believe that an internal succession should be your first step if you have the right people in place. When a firm has institutional clients such as you do with many different relationships within each client organization it can take time to transition relationships to the next generation of attorneys in the firm to ensure that clients stay with the firm when you retire. Transition to the next generation of attorneys usually involves legal skill development, management skill development, and client transition. We often recommend five years.
If you are looking for a buy-in for new equity partners you need sufficient time so new equity partners can pay for their initial ownership interests over time and acquire additional interests as they can afford to acquire more. Waiting too long can also create a situation where non-equity partners in the firm feel they can simply wait your out and inherit the clients without paying anything, or very little, for their ownership interests or buy-in/buyouts. Consider making a few folks minority equity partners as soon as you can.
This assume that any of your non-equity partners even want to be equity partners in the firm which is often the case these days. Three of your non-equity partners may also be close to retirement themselves and have no interest in stepping up to equity. If this is the case you will have to focus on the other two non-equity partners. I would begin a dialog with all of your non-equity partners to determine their interest level. At some point you will not really know until you present them will a proposal and appropriate financial information – initial buy-in if there is to be one and founding buy-outs if there is to be such.
If it looks like the interest or commitment level is not there in your non-equity partners you may have to consider an external option such as a merger. The timeline often can be much shorter in such situations.
Click here for our blog on succession strategies
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC
Question:
I am the sole owner of a five lawyer firm in Indianapolis, Indiana. The other lawyers are associates. Our firm focuses entirely on estate planning and probate and trust administration as well as elder law. I am 60 and do not plan on retiring for another ten years. Two of my associates have been with me for 8-10 years and are vital to my practice as well as my eventual succession and exit strategy. I do not want to lose them so I am considering making them non-equity partners and giving them the title of partner. I am not ready to have any equity partners at this time. I have a production bonus system in place for the associates so I don’t plan on changing their compensation or the system under which they are compensated. How can I make their promotion to partner meaningful?
Response:
Here are some things you might consider:
The title of partner in itself is more important than you might think but it requires that a big a buildup. If you only do one thing – do the buildup announcement and secondly include them more in firm management.
Click here for our blog on partnership
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC