I am the managing partner for a 18 attorney insurance defense firm in Atlanta. We have 6 partners and 12 associates. Most of our associates are seasoned associates and have 10 years plus experience. We are presently paying them a salary plus discretionary bonus. We are having problems with six of the associates not reaching performance goals. (1800 minimum billable hours per year.) While we have some attorneys billing 2400+ hours per year – these six are not – some are billing 1400 hours. What sort of incentive should we be thinking about to improve their performance?
The incentive is to get to continue their employment, maintain a full work schedule, progress to partnership, and to receive future pay raises and bonuses.
I know of some insurance defense firms that pay a billable hour bonus above a certain level. However, this approach often causes other problems such as milking hours in client files and overbilling often resulting in client dissatisfaction and potential loss of key clients. In addition other factors are also important – quality of work, results obtained, teamwork, client relationships (minding) etc. that are often not considered and left out of the equation. Before charging off on such an incentive approach I would first see if you can determine the reasons behind the low hours of the six associates. Do they have enough work? Do they put in enough hours? Are they good time managers and good time keepers? If they have enough work – then meet with each of them – lay out the expectation of 1800 hours and consequences for non-achievement. If they have issues with time management or time keeping impress upon them the importance of improving these skills – in the meantime they may have to simply put in the extra time to get in the hours.
Often motivation is more about getting the right people on the bus than incentive programs. See article on the topic below.
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D, CMC